SDP chief Chee Soon Juan reviews Constructing Singapore: Elitism, Ethnicity and the Nation (Amazon). Wall Street Journal:
The “Singapore Story” — the title of the first volume of founding Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew’s autobiography — is that a mandarinate elite built a bastion of political and economic success on twin pillars of good governance: meritocracy and multiracialism. “Chimeras,” say Michael Barr and Zlatko Skrbis, professors at The Flinders University of South Australia and The University of Queensland, Australia, respectively. The authors tear apart the Lee mythology with commendable academic rigor and gusto, arguing that such propaganda serves only to “facilitate and legitimize rule by a self-appointed elite dominated by middle-class Chinese in general, and by the Lee family in particular.” …
These schemes are designed to support and enhance a political infrastructure where power is concentrated in a select few. If all this seems like social engineering at work, that’s because it is. Mr. Lee has never been shy about his intentions to rear future generations of elites.
A more in-depth examination of the programs and considerable resources used to implement Mr. Lee’s eugenics agenda would provide the reader with a better understanding of the extent to which the Party went to ensuring that the elite reproduced and that the “lumpen masses” (to use Mr. Lee’s term) did not. In the 1980s, the PAP sought to increase fertility among university-educated women through financial incentives and dating services, while providing major subsidies for the voluntary sterilization of poor and uneducated parents. …
How public policy impacts ethnic groups in Singapore is also keenly examined. Ethnic discrimination is carried out at the highest level of government. One prominent indicator is Singapore’s government-sponsored overseas university scholarships to students. Citing statistics from 1966-2007, the authors note that of the 228 President’s Scholarships awarded only 14 (about 6.1%) went to minority ethnic students. The percentage dropped to 3.5% in the years between 1981 and 2007, even though minority ethnic groups make up more than 20% of Singapore’s population. The number of scholarships given by the Singapore Armed Forces to minorities is even more telling: only 2.2% of the awards given between 1971 and 2007 went to non-Chinese recruits. Messrs. Barr and Skrbis point out that it is not so much a question of whether, but rather of how consciously, these selection panels base their decisions on the wishes of Mr. Lee.
Both Mr. Lee and his son, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, have openly stated that Singapore is not ready for a non-Chinese head of government. But in an irony that only autocratic systems can sustain, Mr. Lee has outlawed public discussions of race relations in Singapore. Using The Maintenance of Religious Harmony Act, the government could interpret any discussion of religious issues as stoking racial sentiment, and could potentially detain without trial persons found doing so, putting any honest discussion of the subject in a deep freeze.
Filed under: Book review, Commentary, Newspaper | Leave a Comment
Tags: chee soon juan, constructing singapore, discrimination, elitism, ethnicity, eugenics, fertility, michael barr, nation, race, sdp, zlatko skrbis
State of the Lee
Last spotted: January 26, 2010 in Singapore
Last analyzed: December 13, 2009 in Singapore
Analysis
Mental acuity: Lee seems slower than usual, reading his prepared speech emotionlessly and answerign questions haltingly.
Physical health: Lee stands unassisted and demonstrated use of both hands.
Next expected:
?State of Mrs Lee
Lee Kuan Yew's wife Kwa Geok Choo has been warded at the Neurological Intensive Care Unit of Tan Tock Seng Hospital since her second stroke in May 2008. She suffered a third stroke in June 2008, and sources available to LEEWATCH suggest that she has suffered permanent brain damage and is not expected to recover from her coma.Last reported: September 11, 2008
-
Recent Posts
-
Recent Comments
neversaydie on Reader question: Does LKY live… Singazine on A credible challenge emer… PeterL on About Singazine on Lee: HDB considering imposing … JohnW on About cy on MM Lee gets first look at… joseph low on Archive Incredulous on Singapore Beyond Lee Kuan Yew:… in on Quotes Incredulous on About Feeds
- Twitter
Legal disclaimer: Lee Kuan Yew Watch is independent and unaffiliated. Any opinions expressed are those of article authors, not Lee Kuan Yew Watch.
No Responses Yet to “Review of Constructing Singapore: Elitism, Ethnicity and the Nation-Building project”